The deadly consequences of privilege, rage, and zero self-control came crashing down in Manhattan one March night in 2022—and a beloved Broadway figure paid the ultimate price.
Now, three years later, the woman responsible sits behind bars, while her once-devoted fiancé tries to pick up the pieces of a life he never imagined, as reported by The Daily Mail.
NYC shoving suspect Lauren Pazienza indicted in death of Barbara Gustern https://t.co/7zjUfVqPhX pic.twitter.com/Bnf0uhzMIc
— New York Post (@nypost) April 21, 2022
Elon Musk Called This Financial News ‘Terrifying’
Lauren Pazienza, a spoiled heiress to a Long Island cesspool-drainage fortune, was sentenced to eight-and-a-half years in prison for the senseless and violent death of 87-year-old Barbara Gustern.
Gustern, a legendary voice coach who once trained Blondie’s Debbie Harry, was shoved to the pavement during an unprovoked attack that left her fatally injured.
The woman behind that deadly shove had been partying hard—reportedly drunk, high on marijuana, and possibly medicated with Xanax. After being kicked out of a Manhattan park, Pazienza threw a tantrum, hurled food at her fiancé Naveen Pereira, and stormed off.
Her fiancée is a witness along w/ her parents who helped her hide out for 2 weeks. They should not be permitted to post the bond given these circumstances. @ManhattanDA @AlvinBraggNYC
Lauren Pazienza is shown in her mugshot https://t.co/06PQusOf72 via @MailOnline— Richard Signorelli 🌱🇺🇦 🌊 🇺🇸 🇨🇦 (@richsignorelli) March 23, 2022
FREE Concealed Carry Gun Laws & Reciprocity Map
Moments later, she violently slammed Gustern to the ground after calling her a b*tch. The elderly woman’s head struck the pavement with brutal force, leading to a traumatic brain injury that killed her days later.
Pazienza took a plea deal last fall, pleading guilty to manslaughter and avoiding the 25-year sentence she might have received at trial. Even that lighter sentence didn’t sit well with Debbie Harry, who publicly slammed it as a “failure to administer adequate punishment.”

Image Credit: Facebook Screenshot – Barbara Maier Gustern
While Pazienza tried to vanish—deleting her social media, quitting her job, and stashing her phone—her guilt eventually caught up. Surveillance footage placed her at the scene, watching as emergency responders helped her dying victim. She turned herself in days later.
Pereira, now 30 and employed at Microsoft, says he’s still trying to get his life back in order. He described his ex as “very passionate.”
When he was asked if their engagement was still on, he called the situation “complicated.”
“Obviously, that’s not happening right now. I don’t know what the future holds for us.”
“She’s going to be in prison for a long time—and that’s not changing,” he stated.
Despite Pazienza’s tears in court, her past behavior paints a different picture. Former classmates described her as “pure trouble” and “a danger.” Prosecutors say she tried to cover up her actions for over a week after the attack, showing zero remorse.

Her sentence was even extended six months for her refusal to fully accept responsibility. Gustern’s grandson didn’t mince words either, calling her “lucky” and challenging her to “learn some empathy.”
Even with all this chaos, Pereira says he still hears from Pazienza’s parents. He hasn’t dated since the incident, calling the emotional toll “too painful.” He says she’s taking classes in prison and “trying to restart her life.”
Lauren Pazienza pleaded guilty to manslaughter in the pushing death of a beloved 87-year-old vocal coach. pic.twitter.com/TKCofyOOvK
— Inside Edition (@InsideEdition) August 24, 2023
But here’s the real takeaway: this isn’t just a story of a wasted life and a broken engagement. It’s a sobering example of what happens when unaccountable privilege meets unchecked rage—especially when the justice system still hands out sweetheart deals to the well-connected.
American Made Patriotic Apparel – Save 15% with Promo Code MERICA